View all properties for sale in this community

View SOLD properties in this community

Casey Key is located south of Sarasota, eight miles south of Siesta Key and is surrounded by water with the Gulf of Mexico to the west and Sarasota Bay to the east. Homeowners here enjoy a wonderful, tropical key with private beaches. The land use is restricted to single-family residences. The natural environment and wildlife make Casey Key one of Florida’s most prestigious real estate addresses with one of the highest land values on the coast. The area offers elegance and old-Florida charm.

Active Properties Statistics

Properties On Market

Single Family: 29

Avg. Asking Price

Single Family: $5,449,914

Avg. Beds & baths

Single Family: 4/4

Avg. Asking Price Per Sqft

Single Family: $1536

Sold Properties

Average Asking Price

Single Family: $4,937,500

Average Selling Price

Single Family: $4,299,000

Selling vs Asking Price

Single Family: -12.93%

Avg. Days On Market

Single Family: 119

* These market statistics are not guaranteed to be accurate. The statistics are meant only as an estimate. Contact your agent for more detailed statistics.

Casey Key, Osprey, FL, real estate listings

WELCOME TO ONE OF THE FEW BRAN...

     Nokomis, FL Property Photo
For Sale : $11,900,000

4005 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
Property Address
Development: Casey Key
Status: A-Active, MLS#: TB8353888

View Virtual Tour
  • area icon 7977 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 6
  • bathrooms icon 6
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

This classically designed esta...

     Osprey, FL Property Photo
For Sale : $11,750,000

1216 Casey Key Road
Osprey, FL 34229
Property Address
Development: Casey Key
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4643654

View Virtual Tour
  • area icon 8050 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 5
  • bathrooms icon 6
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

Pre-Construction. To be built....

     Nokomis, FL Property Photo
For Sale : $10,100,000

Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
Property Address
Development: Casey Key
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4628430

View Virtual Tour
  • area icon 5414 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 5
  • bathrooms icon 5
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

Magical sunsets illuminate the...

     Nokomis, FL Property Photo
For Sale : $8,975,000

2821 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
Property Address
Development: Casey Key
Status: A-Active, MLS#: N6137575

View Virtual Tour
  • area icon 6891 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 5
  • bathrooms icon 6
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

This custom-built solid, gulf-...

     Nokomis, FL Property Photo
For Sale : $8,450,000

507 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
Property Address
Development: Casey Key
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4632022

View Virtual Tour
  • area icon 6596 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 5
  • bathrooms icon 6
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

Embrace coastal elegance with...

     Nokomis, FL Property Photo
For Sale : $8,400,000

2110 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
Property Address
Development: Casey Key
Status: A-Active, MLS#: N6137722

View Virtual Tour
  • area icon 5249 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 5
  • bathrooms icon 5
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

Designed by renowned architect...

     Nokomis, FL Property Photo
For Sale : $7,500,000

1304 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
Property Address
Development: Casey Key
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4642022

View Virtual Tour
  • area icon 6041 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 5
  • bathrooms icon 8
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

Priced reduced! Welcome to thi...

     Osprey, FL Property Photo
For Sale : $6,950,000

144 Casey Key Road
Osprey, FL 34229
Property Address
Development: Casey Key
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4636387

View Virtual Tour
  • area icon 5397 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 4
  • bathrooms icon 5
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
EXP REALTY LLC

Welcome to "Toes in the Sand"...

     Nokomis, FL Property Photo
For Sale : $6,799,500

506 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
Property Address
Development: Casey Key
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4634191

View Virtual Tour
  • area icon 3906 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 4
  • bathrooms icon 5
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
CLUB REALTY

This captivating Gulf-to-Bay r...

     Nokomis, FL Property Photo
For Sale : $6,750,000

3300 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
Property Address
Development: Casey Key
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4650208

View Virtual Tour
  • area icon 4350 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 4
  • bathrooms icon 3
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

Coastal Elegance with Gulf Vie...

     Nokomis, FL Property Photo
For Sale : $6,450,000

3625 Casey Key Rd
Nokomis, FL 34275
Property Address
Development: Casey Key
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4635826

View Virtual Tour
  • area icon 5714 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 4
  • bathrooms icon 4
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
COMPASS FLORIDA LLC

Refined comfort in a near-idea...

     Nokomis, FL Property Photo
For Sale : $6,445,000

3909 Casey Key Road
Nokomis, FL 34275
Property Address
Development: Casey Key
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4643566

 
  • area icon 6335 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 4
  • bathrooms icon 4
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY