View all properties for sale in this community

View SOLD properties in this community

Oyster Bay Area

Including Oyster Bay East & Oyster Bay Estates & Oyster Bay Landings

Located on Sarasota Bay this “West of the Trail” neighborhood offers old Florida style mingle with architectural classics in serene, park-like settings. A great location for boaters with deep sailboat waterways and magnificent views of the bay and the neighborhood lake. Oyster Bay is an established area of single-story Florida homes, executive residences and mansion estates. The community offers large lots, bamboo, mature trees, and flowers.

 

Active Properties Statistics

Properties On Market

Single Family: 12

Avg. Asking Price

Single Family: $6,036,375

Avg. Beds & baths

Single Family: 4/4

Avg. Asking Price Per Sqft

Single Family: $1090

Sold Properties

Average Asking Price

Single Family: $1,772,500

Average Selling Price

Single Family: $1,650,000

Selling vs Asking Price

Single Family: -6.91%

Avg. Days On Market

Single Family: 146

* These market statistics are not guaranteed to be accurate. The statistics are meant only as an estimate. Contact your agent for more detailed statistics.

Oyster Bay Area, Sarasota, FL, real estate listings

For Sale : $11,975,000

1329 Lake Shore Drive
Sarasota, FL 34231
Property Address

Development: Oyster Bay Estates
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4590476

  • area icon 6515 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 4
  • bathrooms icon 4
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
EXP REALTY LLC

For Sale : $11,650,000

1136 Lake Shore Drive
Sarasota, FL 34231
Property Address

Development: Oyster Bay Estates
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4591433

  • area icon 10234 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 4
  • bathrooms icon 6
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

Pending : $9,950,000

4410 Camino Real
Sarasota, FL 34231
Property Address

Development: Oyster Bay Estates
Status: Pending, MLS#: A4590855

  • area icon 4988 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 4
  • bathrooms icon 5
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY

For Sale : $8,950,000

1137 Lake Shore Drive
Sarasota, FL 34231
Property Address

Development: Oyster Bay Estates
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4585703

 
  • area icon 6462 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 6
  • bathrooms icon 6
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY

For Sale : $7,500,000

4431 Camino Real
Sarasota, FL 34231
Property Address

Development: Oyster Bay Estates
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4582548

 
  • area icon 5557 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 6
  • bathrooms icon 6
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

For Sale : $6,295,000

1804 Lake Shore Drive
Sarasota, FL 34231
Property Address

Development: Oyster Bay Estates
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4607277

  • area icon 6854 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 4
  • bathrooms icon 4
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
PREFERRED SHORE

For Sale : $3,590,000

1525 Lake Shore Drive
Sarasota, FL 34231
Property Address

Development: Oyster Bay Estates
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4607865

  • area icon 4407 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 4
  • bathrooms icon 3
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

For Sale : $3,350,000

1451 Rebecca Lane
Sarasota, FL 34231
Property Address

Development: Oyster Bay Landings
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4593160

  • area icon 4683 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 4
  • bathrooms icon 5
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY

For Sale : $2,987,500

1801 Field Road
Sarasota, FL 34231
Property Address

Development: Oyster Bay Estates
Status: A-Active, MLS#: A4597699

 
  • area icon 3035 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 3
  • bathrooms icon 4
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
GRECO REAL ESTATE

Pending : $2,499,000

1615 Lake Shore Drive
Sarasota, FL 34231
Property Address

Development: Oyster Bay Estates
Status: Pending, MLS#: A4585802

  • area icon 4329 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 3
  • bathrooms icon 3
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
SARASOTA TRUST REALTY COMPANY

Pending : $1,900,000

1521 Lake Shore Drive
Sarasota, FL 34231
Property Address

Development: Oyster Bay Estates
Status: Pending, MLS#: A4596901

  • area icon 3029 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 4
  • bathrooms icon 4
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
PREMIER SOTHEBYS INTL REALTY

Pending : $1,790,000

1514 Lake Shore Drive
Sarasota, FL 34231
Property Address

Development: Oyster Bay Estates
Status: Pending, MLS#: A4579921

  • area icon 2430 Sqft
  • bedrooms icon 3
  • bathrooms icon 3
  • key icon Save Property

BR Logo Listing Courtesy of:
MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY